营销科学学报 ›› 2015, Vol. 11 ›› Issue (2): 34-50.

• 论文 • 上一篇    下一篇

脱销的利与弊:以感知稀缺性与心理抗拒感为中介的相似品购买意愿研究

李东进,张成虎,李研   

  1. 李东进,南开大学商学院市场营销系教授,博士生导师,Email:djli1280@163.com。 张成虎,通讯作者,南开大学商学院市场营销系博士研究生,E-mail:zhangchenghu_nk@126.com。 李研,首都经贸大学工商管理学院市场营销系讲师,管理学博士,E-mail:liyan_nankai@sina.com。
  • 出版日期:2015-06-01 发布日期:2015-08-28
  • 基金资助:

    本研究得到国家自然科学基金项目“产品虚位现象与消费者反应机制的研究”(71372099)、国家自然科学基金项目“消费者后悔形成机制与效应研究”(71072101)的资助、首都经济贸易大学2015年度科研基金项目“稀缺性营销策略对消费者反应的影响研究”的资助,特此感谢。论文初稿曾在2014年中国营销科学学术年会(厦门大学)宣读,感谢点评专家的建议。另外,非常感谢两位匿名评审专家所提的宝贵修改意见和建议。

Advantage and Disadvantage of Out-of-Stock: Research on Similar Alternative Purchase Intention with Perceived Scarcity and Psychological Reactance as Mediators

Li Dongjin, Zhang Chenghu, Li Yan   

  1. Li Dongjin, Business School, Nankai University.
    Zhang Chenghu, Business School, Nankai University.
    Li Yan, College of Business Administration, Capital University of Economics and Business.
  • Online:2015-06-01 Published:2015-08-28

摘要:

现有研究单纯的关注脱销可能带来的负面情绪(沮丧等),或者仅仅聚焦这种虚位现象所诱发的吸引效应,脱销信息究竟会对相似品购买意愿产生积极还是消极的影响缺乏统一的结论。本文认为,两者之间并不存在确定的正向或者负向关系,并提出了该影响机制的双中介路径模型和相关调节变量。研究表明:当呈现给消费者产品脱销信息时,相比没有脱销信息,消费者会体验到更强的感知稀缺性和心理抗拒;产品脱销(是vs.否)对消费者相似产品购买意愿影响的过程中,感知稀缺性和心理抗拒共同起到了中介作用,且感知稀缺性正向影响相似品购买意向,心理抗拒负向影响相似品购买意向;另外,心理抗拒在产品脱销对购买意向影响中的负向中介作用受到了认知资源占用水平的调节,心理抗拒是一个有调节的中介变量,而感知稀缺性的正向中介作用未受到认知资源占用水平的调节。

关键词: 脱销, 感知稀缺性, 心理抗拒, 双中介模型, 相似品购买意愿

Abstract:

There exist studies that focus on the possible negative emotion (depression for instance) brought by mere concentration on out-of-stock. Or others solely study on the attractive effect induced by phantom alternative. What effect, positive or negative, will out-of-stock alternative impact on the purchase intention of similar alternative is still without a definite conclusion. This paper holds that there is not a certain positive or negative effect on the similar alternative purchase intention. Also, a dual mediation pathway model and relevant moderator of such influence mechanism are proposed. Our research shows that when offered the out-of-stock alternative, consumers seem to experience the stronger emotion of perceived scarcity and psychological reactance compared with no information offered. The effects of out-of-stock message on consumers’ similar alternative purchase intention mediated by scarcity and psychological reactance separately are opposite (positive versus negative). In addition, the negative effect mediated by psychological reactance is moderated by the occupation levels of cognitive resource. Psychological reactance is a moderated mediator. Whereas, the positive mediating effect of perceived scarcity is not affected.

Key words: out-of-stock, perceived scarcity, psychological reactance, dual mediation model, similar alternative purchase intention