营销科学学报 ›› 2014, Vol. 10 ›› Issue (3): 99-112.

• 论文 • 上一篇    下一篇

虚拟社区激励政策对成员参与动机的影响:强化还是削弱?

楼天阳,范钧,吕筱萍,李仪凡,陆雄文   

  1. 楼天阳,浙江工商大学工商管理学院市场营销系副教授,E-mail: loutianyang@mail.zjgsu.edu.cn。
    范  钧,浙江工商大学工商管理学院市场营销系教授,E-mail: fj@mail.zjgsu.edu.cn。
    吕筱萍,浙江工商大学工商管理学院市场营销系教授,E-mail: hzluxp@163.com。
    李仪凡,复旦大学管理学院博士后,E-mail: lyf@fudan.edu.cn。
    陆雄文,复旦大学管理学院教授,E-mail: xwlu@fudan.edu.cn。
  • 出版日期:2014-09-01 发布日期:2014-11-10
  • 基金资助:

    本研究受到国家自然青年基金 “虚拟社区成员持续参与动机演变与激励策略”(71202079),浙江省自然基金“基于LPP理论视角虚拟社区用户持续参与行为的动力机制研究(Y7100626)”资助;非常感谢三位匿名评审专家对本文提出的宝贵意见。

The influence of incentive mechanism of virtual communities on members’ motivation of participation, reinforce or Diminish?

Lou Tianyang, Fan Jun, Lv Xiaoping, Li Yifan, Lu Xiongwen   

  1. Lou Tianyang, Business Administration School, ZheJiang GongShang University;
    Fan Jun, Business Administration School, ZheJiang GongShang University;
    Lv Xiaoping, Business Administration School, ZheJiang GongShang University;
    Li Yifan, Management School, FuDan University;
    Lu Xiongwen,Management School, FuDan University.
  • Online:2014-09-01 Published:2014-11-10

摘要:

基于用户产生内容虚拟社区的维持依赖于社区成员的自愿参与与贡献,因此,越来越多的社区运营者以及商业公司给予贡献者以报酬,那么这种外在的报酬激励是否会挤出参与者内在的分享意愿,目前的研究结论并不一致。本文将虚拟社区的激励策略进一步区分为货币式激励和非货币式激励两种,研究表明:货币式激励对内部动机有显著的削弱作用,但对内部化动机(实用和声誉)的影响并不一致;而非货币式激励对内部及内部化动机都表现为强化作用。内部和内部化动机对参与行为的影响也不一致,其中基于他人导向的利他性动机和声誉动机对社区的贡献参与有正向影响,而基于自我导向的娱乐动机和实用动机均是负向影响。该研究表明在虚拟社区情境中货币式激励政策更多表现出挤出效应,而非货币激励政策更多表现出强化效应,同时讨论了该研究结论的管理启示。

关键词: 货币式激励, 非货币式激励, 内部动机, 外部动机, 参与

Abstract:

The success of User Generated Content Virtual Communities (UGCC) greatly depends on the voluntary participation and continued contribution of their members. Therefore, more and more community operators and companies reward contributors, but there is not well understood: Do incentives will diminish intrinsic motivation of participation? Our study contributes to classify the incentive policies to monetary and non-monetary incentive, and how they influence the motivation of participation. Drawing on theories of SDT, we develop a theoretical model relating the motivations, participation, and performance of community participants. Our results reveal several important ?ndings. First, the monetary incentive will diminish the intrinsic motive while have different influence on the two internal motives (reputation, own-use value); Second, non-monetary incentive has the same positive influence on both intrinsic and internal motives. Third, the intrinsic motive and internal motives have impact on participation behavior in different ways, the other-oriented motives (reputation, altruism) have the significant positive influence, while the self-oriented motives (the enjoyment, own-use) have the significant negative impact on participation. The study shows that monetary incentive has more crowding effect while non-monetary incentive exhibits more reinforcing effect in the UGCC. Lastly, the theoretical contribution and managerial implication were concluded.

Key words: monetary incentive, non-monetary incentive, intrinsic motive, extrinsic motive, participation